|Elliott Sound Products||Project 28|
Parametric And Sub-Woofer Equaliser
Rod Elliott (ESP)
Parametric equalisers are normally quite complex, and allow for variable Q (Quality factor), so the peak or dip can be made sharp or broad. This unit does not allow this, but the Q will vary as the amount of equalisation is varied. Perhaps surprisingly (or perhaps not), this works well in practice, and my unit has more than enough range for 'normal' equalisation tasks.
I tend to feel that if a unit such as this is not capable of removing the problem, then the actual cause of the problem should be investigated, rather than going for more complexity, and more radical variations in the relative phase of the signal.
I do not recommend this unit for hi-fi tone controls! As an equaliser to correct specific problems, it can still be used with care. Bear in mind that parametric EQ is not well understood by most people, and if it is accessible it is potentially dangerous for your loudspeakers. As a diagnostic tool it is extremely useful - if sonic problems are encountered, some experimentation with one (or more) parametric equalisers can be helpful in identifying the nature and magnitude of the problem.
The schematic is shown in Figure 1, and is quite simple. In essence, it uses the same principle as a graphic equaliser, but the simulated inductors are made variable, so the frequency can be swept back and forth. The four 10K pots provide cut (when on the left or anti-clockwise side of centre) or boost, and in the centre position have no effect at all. Maximum boost and cut is about 12 to 14dB (typical).
Figure 1 - The Circuit Of The Parametric Equaliser
The low frequency section can be swept from 35Hz to 150Hz in peaking mode (this is the normal form of operation for a parametric equaliser), but also offers the option of shelving. Shelving is similar to the operation of conventional tone controls, but this is also sweepable, so the frequency can be changed to suit your requirements. Frequency increases as the 1M pots are reduced in value.
There are two mid-range sections, one operating between 120Hz and 550Hz, and the other from 500Hz to 2200Hz. The high frequency EQ is shelving only, and can be switched from 2.5kHz to 5kHz with the values shown. By changing capacitor values, these can be easily modified, or you can use a multi-position switch to add as many frequency points as you want.
The simulated inductor opamps can be TL072 or similar, but the input and output opamps need to be fairly quiet. Use NE5532 or similar.
|IC pinouts for dual opamps are shown in the diagram. Remember that all opamps need bypass capacitors on the supply pins, and I suggest that a
10uF electrolytic is used from both supply rails to earth for the whole board, and 100nF ceramic capacitors should be used as close as possible from each supply
pin to earth. Keep all leads as short as possible.|
If fast opamps are used, you will need to take great pains to ensure that the bypassing is effective to prevent oscillation. The 100 ohm output resistor isolates the opamp output from the capacitance of the output cable.
The treble section is a little inscrutable in this arrangement. The frequency is actually set by R3 and R4, along with the selected treble capacitor. This only applies at maximum boost or cut, and R12 limits the maximum boost and cut, but doesn't change the frequency appreciably. It obviously has some effect, but tone controls of any kind are not precision circuits, and are set to get the sound you want, not to correct for system response errors (although that is possible within limits).
This circuit can also make a very flexible sub-woofer equaliser, by modifying the frequencies and leaving out the treble control (thereby only using three of the 10K pots). The second and third sections can be much the same as the low frequency section, butt without the Shelving switch. Suggested values are C4, 820nF, C5, 39nF (second filter), and C6, 680nF, C7, 33nF (third filter). Use the formulae shown below to calculate the frequencies, and adjust capacitors to suit your needs. The ratio of values determines the filter Q, and maximum Q is achieved when the frequency pots are set to maximum.
With the ability to have two peaking filters, or one shelving and one peaking, the response of a subwoofer (and the listening space) can be tailored quite accurately. Additional bass boost can be added from (say) 50Hz and below, and any strong room resonance can be removed, or a prominent dip filled in.
The input filter provides a -3dB point of 1.6Hz, and if this is too low (few if any subs will go quite that low), it can be made more reasonable by reducing the 1uF cap to 100nF, raising the -3dB point to a more realistic 16Hz. Note that the -3dB point is only accurate when the boost/cut controls are set to the mid position, giving a flat response.
Since this circuit relies on the simulated inductor, it is worth a few words on how these work. The opamp is used only as a buffer (emitter followers can also be used, but are not nearly as good), and uses controlled positive feedback to make the circuit act as an inductor.
Looking at the first section (without the switch, though), there is a 47nF capacitor, 470 Ohm resistor, and a resistance that can be varied from 47k to 1.047M Ohms (the 47k fixed resistor plus 1M Ohm). The approximate formula for the inductance is ...
L = R1 × R2 × C
L = 470 × 50k × 47nF = 1.1 Henrys
... and with the pot at maximum ...
L = 470 × 1.05M × 47nF = 23 Henrys
With a series capacitance of 1µF, and since the resonant frequency is determined by ...
fo = 1 / ( 2 × π × √( L × C ) )
fo = 1 / ( 2 × 3.141 × √( 1.1 × 1µF )) = 151 Hz with the pot at minimum, and ....
fo = 1 / ( 2 × 3.141 × √( 23 × 1µF )) = 33.2 Hz when the pot is set to maximum.
These figures are more than accurate enough for our purposes. With this information, you can modify the frequency ranges to suit any application. Bear in mind that to be able to use these circuits at frequencies above about 3kHz or so, you will need to use fairly fast opamps. The venerable TL072 or its equivalent is probably good enough for most applications, but if additional frequency equalisation sections are to be added, a really quiet opamp should be used for the output stage (as stated above, I would suggest that this is a good idea anyway).
|Copyright Notice. This article, including but not limited to all text and diagrams, is the intellectual property of Rod Elliott, and is Copyright © 1999 - 2006. Reproduction or re-publication by any means whatsoever, whether electronic, mechanical or electro- mechanical, is strictly prohibited under International Copyright laws. The author (Rod Elliott) grants the reader the right to use this information for personal use only, and further allows that one (1) copy may be made for reference while constructing the project. Commercial use is prohibited without express written authorisation from Rod Elliott.|